Will the new ‘CAP’ fit upland farmers?
Although negotiations are still ongoing and a final agreement is not expected until 2027, CAP and the potential impact of a reduced overall budget formed much of the discussion at today’s Uplands Symposium.
Speaking at the event jointly hosted by Teagasc and CAFRE in the Great Southern Hotel, Killarney, Co. Kerry, Head of Rural Economy and Development Programme at Teagasc, Dr. Kevin Hanrahan provided an update on how negotiations are progressing and forecast some potential outcomes.
“Under the current budget proposals, Ireland’s pro-rata €8.161 billion ring-fenced allocation represents the minimum level of income support available through the new CAP to Irish farmers. This represents a ‘headline’ reduction of 23.4% versus the budget for the 2021-2027 period.
“The ring-fenced budget for CAP income support covers Pillar I type payments, including Degressive Area-Based Income Support, coupled payments and the Small Farmer Scheme. It also covers co-financed Pillar II-type payments, such as ANC and payments for agri-environmental and climate actions (AECAs),” Dr. Hanrahan explained.
“Additional national co-financing for schemes such as ACRES, ANC and similar Pillar II measures would increase the total CAP resources supporting farm incomes in Ireland,” he explained.
Based on the European Commission proposal from 2025, the agreements among Ministers for Agriculture reached in October mean that the CAP 2028-2034 is expected to give more flexibility to Member States in designing their CAP plan to address the challenges of economic viability, generational renewal and environmental sustainability. As highlighted later, this may be a potential positive for farmers operating upland systems.
“The ultimate size of the CAP budget in Ireland for the period 2028-2034 will depend on the willingness of the Irish government to co-finance CAP measures,” before adding: “The proposed CAP regulation provides the basis for the continuation of all of the Pillar I and Pillar II type schemes that currently characterise the CAP in Ireland.”
However, uncertainty remains as to how the size of the overall budget, and the whether the scale of national exchequer funds, will stretch to meet these schemes.
“The apportionment of the ring-fenced budget between different measures will be important in determining the total CAP budget. Some CAP measures will be 100% EU financed whereas others will require Member State co-financing. The choice between these Pillar I and Pillar II type measures will also be important in determining how much income support goes to upland farmers and farm systems,” Dr. Hanrahan explained.
Another avenue explored was the possibility that resources from the National and Regional Partnership Fund (NRRP) that have not already been allocated to agriculture could be used to fund CAP measures. However, this may be constrained by the requirement to fund Agricultural Knowledge and Innovation Systems (AKIS) and rural development actions such as LEADER.
“It also depends on how large the ring-fenced CAP budget is relative to the total National and Regional Partnership Fund allocation. In Ireland, there is a relatively small difference between the ring-fenced budget of €8.2 billion and the €11.4 billion for the NRPP,” he added.
CAP post-2027 – an opportunity for upland farming?
As mentioned earlier, the post-2027 CAP era will afford Member States greater freedom to target support at different types of farmers. This, Dr. Hanrahan explained, could be a positive for farmers operating in the uplands.
“The new CAP will give Member States greater freedom to target support at different types of farmers, including by varying DABIS payments according to farmer type.
“Higher DABIS payments are mandatory for young farmers, but Member States can also differentiate area-based payments to other farmer types. For example, targeting may be via coupled supports for sheep or on the first hectares to support smaller farmers. Areas of Natural Constraint (ANC) payments are no longer mandatory but remain an option for Members States.”
Dr. Hanrahan also commented that the next CAP will require European and Irish officials to “make choices about the types of farming they want to prioritise for income support”.
“Farmers in Ireland’s uplands produce food and other public goods valued by Irish and European society. It is increasingly important to make that case. Upland farmers generally operate farm systems with relatively low incomes and a high dependence on CAP support. The case for supporting farmers who need it can be made, but maintaining the value of CAP support will depend on demonstrating what upland farmers deliver through both agricultural output and ecosystem services,” Dr. Hanrahan added.
For farmers concerned about payments next year as a result on the ongoing CAP budget negotiations, Dr. Hanrahan also provided some clarity: “In the absence of an agreement on the budget for 2028-2034, the EU budget in 2027 will be rolled over until a new budget is agreed.”
For more from the Uplands Symposium, including presentations from the event, visit here.
